The Wedding Open Bar Hiring Disaster: Why Pulling Rank on Hiring Is a Fast Track to Failure

It’s Monday morning, and you, the all-powerful CEO, stroll into the office. You’ve just returned from a lavish weekend wedding, and you can’t stop smiling. Between the endless appetizers and an open bar that just wouldn’t quit, you had a great time. But more importantly, you met someone. Someone special. Someone you think is “perfect” for that open VP role you’ve been struggling to fill.

“We really vibed,” you tell your leadership team as you nonchalantly mention hiring this new connection. “We had a great conversation over drinks, and I think they’d be a great fit. Let’s bring them on.”

This is where your leadership team collectively braces for impact because what you’ve just done is the corporate equivalent of using a hammer to hang wallpaper. Just because you can pull rank doesn’t mean you should. And when it comes to hiring decisions, playing the CEO card in this way is almost always a mistake. Let me explain why.

Superiority Complex? You’re Not Above the Hiring Process

Yes, you’re the CEO. Yes, you have the power to make big decisions and override people when you think it’s necessary. But let’s be clear: hiring someone because you shared a couple of laughs at a wedding and “felt a connection” is not you being visionary—it’s you being reckless. You’re treating recruitment like a casual hobby, when it’s actually one of the most critical functions of your business.

Sure, you might feel like you’ve got a golden gut instinct for spotting talent, but I’ve seen this fail 90% of the time. Here’s the harsh truth: your job as CEO is to lead the company, not to micromanage hiring by cutting corners or skipping due diligence because you liked someone at the open bar. That’s not leadership—that’s ego.

Pulling Rank Won’t Save You When This Fails

Hiring isn’t about you making friends or finding someone you “vibe” with. It’s about strategically choosing individuals who will grow your business, lead teams, and solve problems. When you decide to pull rank and hire someone just because you can, you’re sending a clear message to your entire organization: the process doesn’t matter, and your whims override logic.

Let’s break down what happens when you pull rank in hiring decisions:

1. The Wedding Vibes Fade Quickly

That fun-loving, charming person who shared stories over drinks at the wedding? They’re not showing up to the office. Why? Because the person you met at a wedding was in their element: social, casual, and probably a bit tipsy. You saw them at their most charismatic, but charisma doesn’t equal competence. Can they handle the hard conversations, the pressure, the execution? You wouldn’t know because you skipped the vetting process.

2. You’re Skipping Over Experience

Every company worth its salt has a recruitment process for a reason. It’s not about filling time; it’s about protecting the company from bad hires. When you pull rank, you’re skipping steps, missing red flags, and betting your company’s future on a conversation you had while juggling a cocktail. Imagine if your team did the same—bypassing processes just because it felt good in the moment. Would you tolerate it? Of course not.

3. You Think You’re Immune to Bias

Here’s a reality check: you’re not above bias. Just because you’re the CEO doesn’t mean you’ve transcended the human tendency to favor people who are like us or who make us feel good. Social connections and business decisions don’t always mix. In fact, they usually clash. When you make hiring decisions based on personal connections, you're fueling your own bias, not finding the best talent for your company.

What’s the Worst That Could Happen? (Hint: A Lot)

Let’s talk consequences, because there are plenty. When you hire someone based on a fun weekend conversation instead of their qualifications, here’s what you’re looking at:

• Productivity Drains: You’ve now hired someone who probably can’t do the job. They’re fumbling, your team is picking up the slack, and your productivity is plummeting. Congratulations—you’ve just created more problems than you solved.
• Credibility Crash: Think your leadership team doesn’t notice when you pull rank? They notice. And when the person you insisted on hiring turns out to be a disaster, they’re not just questioning that hire—they’re questioning your judgment. You can’t pull rank on that fallout.
• Wasted Resources: Recruitment is costly, both in time and money. You’ve now wasted all of that by hiring someone who’s a bad fit. And when it doesn’t work out (because it won’t), you’re back to square one, starting the process all over again.

Stop Playing King—Play Strategist

So, what should you do if you meet someone socially who seems like a potential hire? Here’s the trick: don’t ignore them, but don’t bypass the process either. If they’re really as great as you think they are, they’ll shine through the formal recruitment process. Let them earn the role, just like anyone else.

You can still advocate for them, but don’t let your personal experience override the system you’ve put in place to protect the business from exactly this kind of impulsive decision. You’re the CEO, not the king of a medieval fiefdom. Playing the “because I said so” card might make you feel powerful, but when that hire crashes and burns, you’ll be left with nothing but a mess to clean up—and that’s not power, that’s poor leadership.

I Offer You This: Hiring Is About the Company, Not You (And you are not the company)

At the end of the day, your job as a CEO is to serve the company, not your personal ego. Recruitment isn’t a place to pull rank. It’s where you need to show restraint and trust the process that’s been built to ensure success. So next time you find yourself wanting to hire someone you “clicked” with at a social event, step back. Enjoy the memory, but let the professionals handle the hiring. You’ve got bigger things to focus on, like leading your company to greatness. Leave the shortcuts at the bar.

‍